How do I confirm an employee after probation, and what goes in the letter?
Track each probation end date, ask the manager for a short written review about two weeks before it, and decide to confirm, extend or part ways in writing. The letter is the last step. Silent confirmation, where nobody decides, is the risk to avoid.
Who asks this: A founder, HR owner or office manager at an Indian company who has several people on probation at once and keeps finding that a probation date passed without anyone deciding anything.
The steps
1. Keep one list of probation end dates
In a sheet, record each person, the joining date, the agreed probation period from their appointment letter and the end date. Sort by end date. The HR owner looks at this list every Monday. A date that lives only in a letter in a drawer is the main reason confirmations are missed.
2. Two weeks before the end, ask the manager
The HR owner sends the manager a short form: what has gone well, what has not, two examples of each, and a recommendation of confirm, extend or end. Ask for the answer within three working days. Use the same form for everyone so the answers can be compared.
3. Hold a review conversation
The manager and the employee meet for twenty minutes. The manager shares the feedback in plain words, the employee responds, and both note what is expected in the next phase. Nobody should hear the decision for the first time in a letter.
4. Decide and record the decision
The founder or the department head makes the decision: confirm, extend for a stated number of weeks with clear goals, or end the employment. Write the decision, the reason and the date in the sheet. If the decision is to end, consult your lawyer or labour adviser before acting.
5. Draft the letter from your own template
A confirmation letter states the employee's name and designation, the date the confirmation takes effect, a line that other terms continue as in the appointment letter and the signatory. An extension letter adds the new end date and the goals. Keep both to one page.
6. Issue it before the date, not after
Send the letter at least a few days before the probation ends and ask the employee to acknowledge it. Keep a signed copy in the personnel file. A letter issued on time shows the process was real.
7. Record the lesson
If a probation ended badly, note in one line what the interview or onboarding missed. After a few months you will see patterns, such as a role that needs a practical test, and can fix hiring rather than only confirmations.
A worked example
illustrative
A 35-person accounting practice in Ahmedabad has three people on probation, ending on 15 December, 3 January and 20 January. On 1 December the manager gets the form for the first. The manager recommends confirming a junior accountant and extending the second hire, whose probation ends on 3 January, by four weeks to 31 January with two clear goals. The confirmation letter is signed on 12 December. For scale, under an illustrative assumption of a salary of twenty-two thousand rupees, three unreviewed months is sixty-six thousand rupees of salary exposure (twenty-two thousand times three). The written review informs the founder, who makes the decision.
What goes wrong
- Nobody notices the end date, and the employee's status is left unclear, with no decision on record.
- The manager's feedback is given for the first time in the letter, and the employee is surprised.
- An extension is announced with no goals, so there is nothing to review at its end.
- The decision is made in a corridor and never written down, so the file is empty.
- Different managers use different standards, and two people in similar roles are treated differently.
- The letter is issued weeks late, and the date on it does not match the decision.
How Demystify OS helps
Mysty WorkersEarly access
Mysty Workers can be set up with you to watch each probation end date from the list you give it, draft a reminder for the manager about two weeks ahead and draft a confirm or extend letter from your own template for HR to review.
Mysty DeskEarly access
Mysty Desk is an approval screen in early access. The HR owner reviews the drafted letter there, and what is sent from it is confirmed with the team before you rely on it.
WhatsAppProvisioned on request
Managers answer a short chat nudge more readily than an email. WhatsApp is a channel on request; the catalogue shows click-to-chat and share links today, so a person opens each drafted reminder in WhatsApp and sends it.
What it does not do. Demystify OS does not decide whether to confirm anyone, give legal advice on ending employment or write letters without your template and approval.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between confirmation and extension?
Confirmation means the probation ends and the employee continues on the agreed terms. Extension means the probation is lengthened for a stated period, with goals. Both should be written, dated and acknowledged by the employee.
Is a probation confirmation letter compulsory?
Practice varies, and your appointment letter may promise one. Whether or not you must issue it, a short written confirmation protects both sides, because it records the date and ends the uncertainty for the employee.
What if I forget to confirm on time?
Decide as soon as you notice, confirm in writing and note the delay honestly. Check your appointment letter for what it says happens at the end of probation. If unsure of the position, ask your lawyer or labour adviser.
What should I tell an employee whose probation is extended?
Say plainly why, which goals must be met, by what date and who will review. An extension without goals feels like punishment and leads to the same problem again at the end of it.
Who should sign the letter?
Whoever signed the appointment letter, or an authorised person such as the HR head or a director. Use the same signatory pattern for every employee so the letters look consistent in the file.
Apply for the beta.
Demystify OS is invite only, and a person reads every application.
Apply for the beta